The Mets All-Time “2 Guys” Team: Catcher


You know, Mike, there are always those players you admire because, to use a cliche, they’ve got heart. Call it toughness, grit, determination, guts. These are the hard-nosed guys who come to play, day in, day out. Their uniforms get dirty, and they never back down from a fight. They are, I mean to say, our kind of players. The ones who make you think, Give me fifteen more players like that, and we’ll hoist a flag.


So we are not talking about Roberto Alomar. Yes, you have to love tough guys. I do think that many times teams that win have tough characters, which builds their overall team chemistry.


And even beyond the issues of winning and losing, these are the types of players we root for, the blue-collar types. So what I’d like to do is name The Mets All-Time “2 Guys” Team. Let’s start with catcher. Obviously, Mike Piazza is the greatest catcher the Mets have ever had — I stood at salute every time he came to the plate — but he doesn’t make the “2 Guys” Team. Nope, this race comes down to two tough sons-of-bitches: John Stearns and Jerry Grote.


Grote was a tough guy and would be my choice for all-time Mets defensive catcher. But this one to me is hands down, John “Bad Dude” Stearns. John actually acquired that name when he was a star football player at Colorado. “Bad Dude” was a great football player and a tough one but he cemented his place on this team with his exploits as a baseball player.

Dave Parker needed his own football helmet after running into “Bad Dude”

Baserunners tried to score against Stearns at their own risk. He broke none other than Dave Parker’s jaw in a violent collision at the plate. Stearns had his teammates’ backs too. He is famous for a body slam he performed on Bill Gullickson. Bill had thrown at teammate Mike Jorgensen, and Stearns charged out of the dugout to the mound and leveled Gullickson.


Stearns, the #2 overall pick by the Phillies in the 1973 draft (Robin Yount was #3, Dave Winfield #4), starred on some awful teams, so he was like an oasis in the desert. On three separate seasons — ’77, ’80, ’82 — he was the Mets lone All-Star representative. We could be proud of John. Mazzilli preened and fans adored him, but all Stearns did was play hard. Too hard, maybe. Injuries limited Stearns to just under 800 games across eight full seasons, 1975-82. There are more fun stories. He once took a run at Braves mascot Chief Noc-A-Homa. Stearns recalled it this way: “I watched him for three or four years and I said, ‘Someday I’m going to clothesline this guy.’ One day I took off, running at him like a defensive back. He looked at me like, ‘What is this guy going to do?’ I didn’t really hit him. I kind of dragged him down. It was just a fun thing but Joe Torre was our manager and he didn’t like it.” John was also the bench coach who famously barked, after an ice-cold Mike Piazza doubled in Game 1 of the 2000 NLCS, “The monster is out of the cage!” There are other great Stearns stories. Didn’t he once tackle a fan?


That is the legend, yes, that a fan had ran onto the field and Stearns buried him into the ground before Security could get to him. I have to admit though, to no personal recollection of that incident.

In any event there is plenty of hard evidence that I can attest to that Bad Dude Stearns was a rough customer. Congratulations to our first member of our “2 Guys Team.” We began, of course, with a catcher because, if you don’t have a catcher you are going to have a lot of passed balls.




Share and Enjoy

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS


  1. Don Patten says:

    I remember the game that he took down an idiot who ran onto the field. As I recall, it was not quite a Mike Curtis moment, but great none the less.

  2. Florida Met Fan Rich says:

    Sorry boys! I don’t think this one is even close! I have to vote for Jerry Grote. He wasn’t named “Red A**” for nothing. This guy was all business and win at all costs.

    The pitchers were totally in fear of him. If you didn’t throw the pitch he called, he would fire the ball back to pitcher as fast as it came in to him.

    We won the 69 World Series with pitching and and Jerry Grote handled our young pitchers perfectly.

    I am wondering if you guys are old enough to have seen him play?

    • Yeah, sadly, we are both old enough. Speaking for Mike, we love Grote and consider him the best defensive catcher in Met history, easy. You are correct, I remember how he fired the ball back to the mound when he was angry. In the end we went with Stearns, but Grote was a strong contender.

    • Michael Geus says:

      I certainly understand any votes for Grote. I loved him and consider him the best defensive catcher I have ever seen, for any team. And I am old enough to have seen every catcher – from Hobie Landrith to Kelly Shoppach.

  3. Alan K. says:

    Grote certainly deserves to be in the discussion. But he had the benefit of playing on better teams and working with better pitchers than Stearns did.

  4. […] week we named our catcher for the Mets All-Time “2 Guys” Team. Now we move to first base, and the winner was not […]

Leave a Reply